Key Takeaways
- A divest-and-exclude approach toward carbon-intensive companies and industries may be overly focused on mitigating perceived risk in the shorter term and could remove return opportunities in actively managed investment strategies over the longer term.
- Portfolio decarbonization is not the same as real-world emissions reduction. For investors focused on true decarbonization of the economy, maintaining a seat at the table as a voting shareholder may be more effective.
- Rather than avoiding carbon-intensive businesses, a sector-relative approach focused on best-in-class companies positioned to win over the long term provides active portfolio managers with a broader investment universe for identifying best ideas.
Investments in the energy transition economy can help support sustainability goals for endowments and foundations interested in taking a less restrictive approach. To learn more about this topic, please read What portfolios may miss by divesting from fossil fuels by Fidelity’s Sustainable Investing team.
What divest-and-exclude strategies focused on carbon-intensive companies overlook
There are many factors that nonprofits consider when constructing a portfolio, and the degree to which they should integrate sustainability is often debated by committee members. For endowments especially, they often consider views from their student stakeholders in their investment discussions. When posed with the topic of potentially divesting and excluding carbon-intensive companies and industries, it is worth considering that a divest-and-exclude approach to tackling portfolio carbon emissions is often skewed toward historical carbon emission data and may not be representative of the future emissions profile of the issuer.
We believe a divest-and-exclude approach is often narrowly focused on curtailing exposure to historical emitters by removing those companies from their opportunity set. Importantly, for actively managed funds, this approach may also remove potential return opportunities to invest in companies that may have historically been high emitters but are now proactively working on emission-reduction solutions. These innovations may represent small portions of the businesses of higher-emitting companies today, but many active investors believe these companies can provide attractive returns in the future as the transition to a lower carbon economy evolves. As a result, staying invested in large incumbents in thoughtful ways can be important for investors looking to generate transition-based returns.
Consider the impact on real-world emissions, not just portfolio emissions
Divesting or excluding carbon-intensive assets may have an impact on a portfolio’s carbon footprint, but doing so will not necessarily have a real-world impact on global carbon emissions. Even after an institution divests, a carbon-intensive company will continue to operate for the benefit of its remaining shareholders. Investors can leverage research and engagement to determine if a company’s transition plan presents financially material risks and/or opportunities to achieve long-term performance, while keeping an eye toward intended real-world outcomes.
Not all carbon-intensive companies are created equal
For actively managed strategies with constraints on tracking error, it is often limiting to exclude entire industries or segments of the market from the opportunity set. Rather than avoiding whole sectors altogether based on backward-looking emission data, taking a sector-relative approach allows investors to focus on best-in-class companies positioned to win while maintaining exposure to the industry. It allows managers’ active risk budgets to be directed toward high-conviction investment ideas rather than sector or industry exclusions.
Conclusion
Taking a blanket divest-and-exclude approach to decarbonization may be a quick way to decarbonize a portfolio; however, we view divestment as a blunt tool that may have unintended consequences and limited real-world emission impact. In our view, active investing offers better ways to navigate in carbon-intensive sectors.
Learn more about Fidelity Institutional Solutions for Endowments and Foundations
To access more content please visit Fidelity’s Communities on Alternative Investments.
Unless otherwise expressly disclosed to you in writing, the information provided in this material is for educational purposes only. Any viewpoints expressed by Fidelity are not intended to be used as a primary basis for your investment decisions and are based on facts and circumstances at the point in time they are made and are not particular to you. Accordingly, nothing in this material constitutes impartial investment advice or advice in a fiduciary capacity, as defined or under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 or the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, both as amended. Fidelity and its representatives may have a conflict of interest in the products or services mentioned in this material because they have a financial interest in the products or services and may receive compensation, directly or indirectly, in connection with the management, distribution, and/or servicing of these products or services, including Fidelity funds, certain third-party funds and products, and certain investment services. Before making any investment decisions, you should take into account all of the particular facts and circumstances of your or your client’s individual situation and reach out to an investment professional, if applicable.
Investing involves risk, including risk of loss.
Diversification and asset allocation do not ensure a profit or guarantee against loss.
Registered investment products (including mutual funds and ETFs) and collective investment trusts managed by Fidelity Management Trust Company (FMTC) are offered by Fidelity Distributors Company LLC (FDC LLC), a registered broker-dealer.
Fidelity Institutional Asset Management (FIAM) investment management services and products are managed by the Fidelity Investments companies of FIAM LLC, a U.S. registered investment adviser, or Fidelity Institutional Asset Management Trust Company, a New Hampshire trust company. FIAM products and services may be presented by FDC LLC, a non-exclusive financial intermediary affiliated with FIAM and compensated for such services.
Fidelity Investments is an independent company, unaffiliated with Institutional Investor LLC. There is no form of legal partnership, agency affiliation, or similar relationship between your financial advisor and Fidelity Investments, nor is such a relationship created or implied by the information herein. Fidelity Investments is a registered service mark of FMR LLC. Fidelity Investments® provides investment products through Fidelity Distributors Company LLC; clearing, custody, or other brokerage services through National Financial Services LLC or Fidelity Brokerage Services LLC, Members NYSE, SIPC; and institutional advisory services through Fidelity Institutional Wealth Adviser LLC.
1160366.2.0